GTA VI reviews are in: a 99 on Metacritic, and what critics actually said
It ties Ocarina of Time for the highest score Metacritic has ever given. Here's what reviewers loved, the few things they didn't, and what it means for Thursday.
The first verdict on GTA VI is about as close to unanimous as it gets. It sits at 99 on Metacritic.
The review embargo lifted at 6 am ET today, Kotaku reported. A leaker had pointed to this date, and we flagged it last week. When we checked at about 10 am ET, Metacritic had counted more than 140 critic reviews, and it rated none of them mixed or negative. Kotaku points out that only one other game has ever scored 99 there: The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Expect the number to move as more reviews come in.
Everything below is spoiler-free. No plot, no missions, no endings.
What the critics said
Five of the reviews we read in full:
- Game Informer: 10. Matt Miller writes that "the level of detail everywhere is astounding and, at times, overwhelming."
- VGC: 5/5. Jordan Middler calls it "Rockstar operating at the absolute peak of its power."
- Vice: 10/10. Brent Koepp calls it "the most impressive open world game ever released."
- Kotaku: no score. Kotaku doesn't score its reviews. Zack Zwiezen calls the game "a masterpiece of open-world design."
- CGMagazine. No number on the page, but Metacritic lists the Canadian outlet's review at 100. Marcus Kenneth says small, unscripted encounters "make the world feel far more alive than in any previous entry."
The world is the headline
Most of the reviews come back to Leonida. Zwiezen calls it "the most detailed, gorgeous, and alive open world I've ever experienced in a video game."
Vice says the game "feels like a living world, with characters that actually interact with emergent events or actions the player takes." Game Informer says it "delights in life's minutiae, with animations, voice lines, and background characters that keep things fresh."
Our piece on the little details Rockstar walked The Guardian through covered a guided demo. These are people who have now spent dozens of hours in it, and they're saying the same thing.
How it plays
The shooting has changed. VGC says GTA VI "ditches aggressive lock-on for third-person shooting that's weighty and satisfying." Game Informer agrees: "Ranged combat is punchy and enjoyable."
Breaking the law takes more work this time. Kotaku says "crime isn't as easy as it has been in the past, which makes it so much more rewarding and fun."
The complaints
There are a few, and they're worth knowing before Thursday.
- Frame rate. Kotaku notes "the game runs at 30FPS, even on PS5 Pro." VGC says that in the densest areas "things can slow down somewhat," then adds, "These moments were few and far between." That fits the 30 fps target Rockstar announced earlier this month. CGMagazine went the other way, reporting no "bugs or performance issues at all."
- Controls. Kotaku says "a classic Rockstar problem is back" with "clunky controls."
- Missions on rails. Game Informer says many missions "feel a bit on rails regarding where to go and what to do at each step."
- Police and money. Vice warns that "some may find police presence to be a bit overwhelming," though "Rockstar does give players a lot of tools to lower their heat or wanted levels." If you want to finish everything, "money is a big factor," and "you may have to grind a bit."
None of it cost much. Every outlet here that printed a score gave full marks.
What it means for Thursday
GTA VI unlocks at midnight local time on Thursday, November 19, on PS5 and Xbox Series X|S. Our unlock times story has the details.
So go in expecting a world worth wandering and gunplay that feels new. Also go in expecting 30 fps, controls that take some getting used to, and missions that tell you exactly where to go.
A 99 doesn't make a game flawless. Four of the five reviewers we read named a real problem. What the score does tell you is that none of the more than 140 critics Metacritic had counted came away lukewarm. At midnight, you get to find out for yourself.
More in Release
Sources
Sources (7)
- Grand Theft Auto VI critic reviews (Metacritic, checked November 18, 2026, about 10:00 am ET)
- GTA 6 Debuts With An Astonishing 99 Metacritic Score, Currently Tied For Best-Reviewed Game Of All Time (Kotaku, Lewis Parker, November 18, 2026)
- Grand Theft Auto 6: The Kotaku Review (Kotaku, Zack Zwiezen, November 18, 2026)
- Grand Theft Auto VI review (Game Informer, Matt Miller, November 18, 2026)
- Grand Theft Auto 6 review (VGC, Jordan Middler, November 18, 2026)
- GTA 6 Review – Rockstar's Magnum Opus (Vice, Brent Koepp, November 18, 2026)
- Grand Theft Auto VI (PS5) review (CGMagazine, Marcus Kenneth, November 18, 2026)